Extra virgin olive oil is so pure and non-irritating that you can safely use it around the eyes to remove makeup.

Pour a small amount of olive oil onto a clean cotton pad and gently wipe over your eyelashes and eyelids.  Or, you can do as I usually do — pour a small amount in one hand and with the fingers of your other hand, smooth the olive oil over your eyes and eyelids. Then I use a soft tissue to remove the makeup.

Not only will all of your eye makeup be completely gone, the delicate skin around your eyes will be moisturized and glowing.